Among these ice cube trays, my best overall pick is the OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Trays, 2-Pack, which pairs a flexible release design with lids for everyday freezing. The Kitch Easy-Release 2-Pack is a straightforward choice if you want traditional trays, while the DOQAUS Tray Set with Storage Bin and Scoop suits people who want an all-in-one storage setup. The main tradeoffs are easy release versus rigid stability, and simple trays versus larger kits that take up more room. Silicone models with lids offer portion variety, but a greater piece count can mean more parts to wash and store. Read on for how all 15 options compare and which features fit your freezer and routine.
Get the little things that make your day delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- OXO is the strongest all-around fit for shoppers who want a practical pair of covered trays without committing to a larger bin-and-accessory kit.
- Kitch’s two-pack and four-pack offer different levels of the same basic setup: choose the smaller set for ordinary use, or the larger set when you want more traditional tray capacity.
- Weftnom’s five-pack and Tohsssik’s five-pack both emphasize batch-making, while the Weftnom set is described as 70 cubes and Tohsssik adds stackable silicone trays with lids.
- Storage kits solve a different problem from tray-only sets: NFK and the DOQAUS bin options are aimed at keeping finished cubes together and accessible, with the scoop-equipped DOQAUS set adding another accessory.
- The lineup spans simple rigid trays and flexible silicone sets, so release preference, freezer space, and willingness to manage lids and parts matter more than pack count alone.
| ice cube tray | Brand |
|---|---|
| OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cu | OXO |
| Kitch Easy-Release Ice Cube Tr | Kitch |
| Kitch Easy-Release White Ice C | Kitch |
| Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Tray | Weftnom |
| ChefAide 4-Pack Silicone Ice C | ChefAide |
| Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Tray | Weftnom |
| DOQAUS Silicone Ice Cube Trays | DOQAUS |
| Arrow Eezy Out Ice Cube Trays | Arrow Home Products |
| Amytor Silicone Ice Cube Trays | Amytor |
| Tohsssik 5-Pack Stackable Sili | Tohsssik |
| NFK Ice Cube Tray Set with Lid | — |
| DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid | DOQAUS |
| DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray Set with | DOQAUS |
| Rubbermaid Easy Release Ice Cu | Rubbermaid |
| Jrisbo Silicone Ice Cube Trays | Jrisbo |
More Details on Our Top Picks
OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 2-Pack
The OXO Good Grips two-pack is my pick for everyday drink makers who want a few cubes without exposing the rest of the tray. Its sliding lids let you take selected cubes while keeping the remaining ice covered, a more flexible approach than the snap-on lids on the Weftnom and ChefAide sets. The lids also help limit freezer odors and let the trays stack, useful when shelf space is tight. OXO makes rounded cubes that are described as easy to release, though this set does not list a total cube count, so buyers focused on high-volume batches may prefer the Kitch four-pack’s stated 64-cube capacity. The tradeoff is a two-tray quantity and plastic construction rather than silicone-bottom release. I’d choose it for controlled access and covered storage, not maximum output.
Pros:- Sliding lids allow selected cubes to be removed while the rest stay covered
- Lids help protect ice from freezer odors
- Stackable design makes better use of freezer space
- Rounded cubes are designed for easy release
Cons:- Only two trays are included, less capacity than the Kitch four-pack or Weftnom five-pack
- Plastic construction may not suit buyers who prefer flexible silicone-bottom release
Best for: Households that use ice a little at a time and want covered, stackable trays to help keep the remaining cubes clear of freezer odors.
Not ideal for: Hosts or large households who need a clearly stated high-capacity batch, or buyers specifically seeking silicone-bottom trays.
- Brand:OXO
- Quantity:2 trays
- Material:Plastic
- Cube shape:Round
- BPA-free:Yes
- Dimensions:12.2 × 5.6 × 1.75 inches
- Dishwasher safe:Top-rack safe
- Item weight:1.1 pounds
Our verdict“Choose the OXO set if covered storage and access to individual cubes matter more than maximizing batch capacity.”
Kitch Easy-Release Ice Cube Trays, 16 Cubes per Tray, Pack of 2, White
For buyers who want a straightforward set without lids or specialty materials, the Kitch two-pack keeps the job simple: two flexible trays make 32 cubes total, and twisting the plastic helps release them. That capacity is clearly stated, unlike the OXO set, which does not specify its cube total; but it is half the 64 cubes offered by Kitch’s own four-pack. These trays also stack, are BPA-free, and can go in the dishwasher, so routine storage and cleanup are covered without extra parts. The tradeoff is the absence of lids: compared with the OXO or ChefAide trays, these offer no stated barrier against spills or freezer odors. I’d pick this set for modest daily use and uncomplicated ice making, while frequent entertainers should step up to the four-tray Kitch pack.
Pros:- Two trays provide a stated total capacity of 32 cubes
- Flexible plastic twists to help release cubes
- Stackable design helps organize freezer space
- BPA-free and dishwasher-safe
Cons:- No lids to help prevent freezer odors or spills
- Lower capacity than the Kitch four-pack, which makes 64 cubes
- Plastic trays lack the silicone bottoms offered by ChefAide
Best for: Small households or occasional ice users who want two easy-release trays, a defined 32-cube capacity, and simple dishwasher cleanup.
Not ideal for: People who need covered ice storage, want to keep odors away, or regularly need more than 32 cubes per batch.
- Brand:Kitch
- Pack size:2 trays
- Cubes per tray:16
- Total capacity:32 cubes
- Material:Plastic
- BPA-free:Yes
- Dishwasher safe:Yes
- Country of manufacture:USA
Our verdict“Pick this pair for uncomplicated, moderate ice needs; choose Kitch’s four-pack if you routinely need a larger batch.”
Kitch Easy-Release White Ice Cube Trays, 16 Cubes per Tray, Pack of 4
When quantity matters more than covered storage, the Kitch four-pack is the clearest high-capacity choice in this group: four flexible trays make 64 cubes, twice the output of the Kitch two-pack. The trays twist to help release ice and stack without sticking together, while BPA-free plastic and dishwasher-safe care keep the setup uncomplicated. Compared with the Weftnom five-pack, Kitch supplies fewer cubes—64 rather than 70—but avoids a silicone-bottom and frame design. Neither Kitch set includes lids, so it gives up the odor protection found on the OXO, Weftnom, and ChefAide options. The four trays also take more freezer room than a two-tray set when stored together. I’d choose this pack for regular batch making, especially if you want a straightforward plastic tray rather than added lid features.
Pros:- Four trays make 64 cubes in total
- Flexible trays twist to help release cubes
- Stacking design helps keep trays separated in the freezer
- BPA-free and dishwasher-safe
Cons:- No lids to shield ice from freezer odors or spills
- Four trays need more storage space than the Kitch two-pack
- Capacity is slightly below the 70 cubes in the Weftnom five-pack
Best for: Families, meal-preppers, or frequent hosts who want a larger batch of ordinary cubes and prefer simple flexible plastic trays.
Not ideal for: Buyers with limited freezer space or anyone who needs lids to protect ice from odors and spills.
- Brand:Kitch
- Quantity:4 trays
- Cubes per tray:16
- Total capacity:64 cubes
- Material:Plastic
- BPA-free:Yes
- Dishwasher safe:Yes
- Warranty:Limited 1 year
Our verdict“Choose this Kitch set for a large, no-frills batch of cubes, but look to Weftnom if lids and slightly higher capacity matter more.”
Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 5-Pack, 70 Cubes
The Weftnom five-pack combines the largest stated capacity here with covered storage: its five trays make 70 cubes, six more than the Kitch four-pack, and snap-on lids help limit spills and freezer odors. Soft silicone bottoms are paired with sturdy PP frames, a combination intended to make cubes easier to release without leaving the whole tray unsupported. That structure also distinguishes it from the simpler flexible-plastic Kitch trays, which stack but do not have lids. The tradeoff is more pieces to store and clean, and the product description gives no tray dimensions or individual cube measurements to help buyers check freezer fit or drink size. The trays can also freeze coffee, juice, herbs, sauces, and baby food, though that versatility may be unnecessary for someone who only needs ordinary drink ice.
Pros:- Five trays make 70 cubes total
- Silicone bottoms and PP frames are designed to support easy release
- Snap-on lids help prevent spills and freezer odors
- Dishwasher-safe trays can also freeze coffee, juice, herbs, sauces, and baby food
Cons:- Five trays and lids require more storage and handling than the Kitch two-pack
- No dimensions or cube size are provided in the product data
- The higher capacity may be unnecessary for buyers who only make occasional ice
Best for: Large households and batch makers who want a high cube count, lidded stacking, and trays that can freeze small portions beyond water.
Not ideal for: Buyers with very limited freezer space, or shoppers who want detailed tray dimensions before choosing a set.
- Brand:Weftnom
- Number of trays:5
- Cubes per tray:14
- Total capacity:70 cubes
- Materials:Silicone bottom with PP frame
- Lids:Snap-on
- BPA-free:Yes
- Dishwasher safe:Yes
Our verdict“Choose Weftnom if you need the lineup’s highest stated capacity alongside lids; skip it if a compact, simple set is your priority.”
ChefAide 4-Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids
The ChefAide four-pack is a practical middle ground for buyers who want covered trays but do not need the Weftnom set’s five trays and 70-cube capacity. It makes 56 rectangular cubes, with silicone bases intended to release ice easily and removable lids that help shield cubes from freezer odors. The set is also described as suitable for baby food, giving the small compartments another use beyond drinks. Compared with the OXO pair, ChefAide offers more trays and a stated capacity, but its lids are removable rather than sliding, so they do not provide the same selective access while the rest stays covered. One practical caveat is that the lids may be easier to remove after waiting about 30 seconds. I’d choose it for portioning and covered storage, not for the fastest access or largest batch.
Pros:- Four trays make 56 cubes total
- Silicone bases are designed to make cubes easier to release
- Removable lids help protect ice from freezer odors
- Suitable for drinks and baby food, and dishwasher-safe
Cons:- Lids may be easier to remove after waiting about 30 seconds
- Each tray makes 14 cubes, fewer than the 16-cube Kitch trays
- Total capacity is below Weftnom’s 70-cube set
Best for: Caregivers and households who want several covered trays for ice or small portions of baby food, with silicone bases for release.
Not ideal for: Frequent entertainers seeking the highest capacity, or users who want to remove individual cubes without taking off a lid.
- Brand:ChefAide
- Pack count:4 trays
- Cubes per tray:14
- Total capacity:56 cubes
- Materials:Silicone and food-grade PP
- Shape:Rectangular
- Dimensions:6 × 3 × 1 inches
- Features:Stackable, removable lids, dishwasher-safe, BPA-free
Our verdict“Choose ChefAide for covered, flexible trays that can also portion baby food, but pick Weftnom for greater ice capacity.”
Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 3 Pack
The three-tray format gives this Weftnom set a useful middle ground: more capacity than the two-tray Amytor set, without committing to the five trays in the Tohsssik set. Its flexible silicone bases are meant to make cube release easier than with the rigid Arrow Eezy Out trays, while polypropylene rims and lids give each tray more structure for filling and stacking. The lids help guard against spills and freezer odors, though the description does not say they seal airtight. The trays are also dishwasher-safe, which keeps cleanup straightforward. My main reservation is that neither the number of cubes per tray nor the tray dimensions are specified, so it is harder to judge capacity and fit before buying. Choose it for covered, stackable everyday freezing; skip it if exact cube counts matter.
Pros:- Three trays offer more batch capacity than the two-tray Amytor set
- Flexible silicone bases help release cubes
- Lids support spill-resistant storage and help limit freezer odors
- Dishwasher-safe construction simplifies cleanup
Cons:- Cube capacity per tray is not specified
- Tray dimensions are not provided, making freezer-fit planning difficult
- Lids are described as spill-resistant, not airtight
Best for: Households wanting several lidded, stackable trays and easier cube release without a five-tray set.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a confirmed cube count or exact tray dimensions to plan freezer space.
- Brand:Weftnom
- Tray count:3
- Materials:Silicone and polypropylene
- BPA-free:Yes
- Dishwasher-safe:Yes
- Color:Sage green
- Shape:Square
- Item weight:0.31 kg
- Model number:ICT-3P-14-MG
Our verdict“Choose this set if you want three flexible, covered trays, but pick Amytor if a stated cube count is a priority.”
DOQAUS Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 4-Pack
For shoppers who put documented material standards high on the list, the LFGB certification and BPA-free materials give this four-pack a clearer specification story than the Weftnom three-pack. All four trays have flexible silicone bottoms for pressing cubes out, and their removable lids make stacking and spill-resistant storage easier. The stated size details also help with planning, although the lids are not airtight and allow airflow. That means they can help reduce spills, but they are not a complete barrier against freezer odors. Compared with the Amytor two-pack, DOQAUS supplies twice as many trays, but Amytor specifies its cube count while this listing does not. I would favor DOQAUS for buyers who want a larger certified-material set; those needing known batch capacity should look for a tray with a stated count.
Pros:- Four trays provide more simultaneous batches than the Amytor two-pack
- LFGB-certified and BPA-free materials are specified
- Flexible bottoms make cube release easier
- Removable lids allow stacking and help resist spills
Cons:- Lids are not airtight and allow airflow
- Cube capacity per tray is not stated
- The listing gives both overall dimensions and a separate size, which may require checking against available freezer space
Best for: Buyers seeking a multi-tray silicone set with stated LFGB certification and BPA-free materials.
Not ideal for: People who need airtight odor protection or a confirmed number of cubes per tray.
- Brand:DOQAUS
- Tray count:4
- Materials:Food-grade silicone and polypropylene
- Certifications:LFGB certified; BPA-free
- Dimensions:10 × 4.1 × 3 in
- Listed size:7.2 × 4.1 × 1.3 in
- Shape:Square
- Care:Dishwasher-safe
- Lid:Removable, spill-resistant, not airtight
Our verdict“Pick DOQAUS for four flexible trays with stated material certification, but choose Amytor if a precise cube count matters more.”
Arrow Eezy Out Ice Cube Trays, 2-Pack
The Arrow Eezy Out set is the straightforward choice here: two rigid plastic trays, each with a stated 14-cube capacity, for a predictable 28 cubes per batch. Their interlocking design makes stacking neater than placing loose trays on top of each other, and the BPA-free plastic keeps the construction simple. Compared with the silicone Amytor trays, these do not offer flexible bases or lids, so releasing cubes may take more effort and the ice is less protected from freezer odors or spills. In return, the Arrow trays avoid the soft, flexible construction that some buyers would rather not handle when carrying a full tray. The assorted color is a small loss of control, and no dishwasher-care details are provided. I’d choose these for basic, countable ice making rather than covered storage or easy-release performance.
Pros:- Each tray has a stated 14-cube capacity
- Interlocking design supports orderly stacking
- BPA-free plastic construction
- Made in the USA
Cons:- Rigid plastic lacks the easy-press release of the silicone Amytor trays
- No lids to help prevent spills or protect ice from freezer odors
- Color is assorted, and dishwasher-care details are not specified
Best for: Shoppers who want a simple two-tray set with a known 14-cube layout per tray.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want lids, flexible cube release, or stated dishwasher-care guidance.
- Brand:Arrow Home Products
- Pack size:2 trays
- Capacity:14 cubes per tray
- Material:Plastic
- BPA-free:Yes
- Color:Assorted
- Country of origin:USA
- Item weight:6.4 ounces
Our verdict“Choose Arrow for simple, countable ice production; opt for Amytor if flexible release and lidded storage matter more.”
Amytor Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Removable Lids, 2 Pack
Amytor is the clearest choice for buyers who want to know exactly how much a compact set makes: 14 cubes per tray and 28 total. The two trays pair flexible TPE silicone bottoms with removable lids, so cubes are easier to press out and the contents are better shielded from dust and freezer odors than in the lidless Arrow Eezy Out set. They’re also dishwasher-safe and can handle foods such as herbs, sauces, juice, and purees, giving the trays uses beyond plain ice. There are some care quirks: the maker recommends soaking or boiling before first use to remove odor, and cautions against metal brushes and strong detergents. Compared with the DOQAUS four-pack, Amytor makes fewer trays available at once, but its explicit cube count and dimensions make capacity easier to plan.
Pros:- Clear capacity of 14 cubes per tray and 28 total
- Flexible bottoms help release cubes with less effort
- Removable lids help protect contents from spills, dust, and freezer odors
- Dishwasher-safe and suitable for freezing foods beyond water
Cons:- Only two trays, fewer than the DOQAUS four-pack
- First-use instructions recommend soaking or boiling to remove odor
- Care guidance advises against metal brushes and strong detergents
Best for: Small households and meal-preppers who want a two-tray set with clearly stated capacity and flexible release.
Not ideal for: Anyone needing many trays for large batches or wanting care instructions without a first-use odor-removal step.
- Brand:Amytor
- Material:PP and TPE silicone
- Tray count:2
- Cubes per tray:14
- Total capacity:28 ice cubes
- Tray dimensions:25.2 × 10.2 × 2.5 cm each
- Ice cube dimensions:4.3 × 3 × 1.8 cm
- BPA-free and dishwasher-safe:Yes
- Lids:Removable
Our verdict“Choose Amytor if you want a compact lidded set with a known 28-cube capacity and do not mind its specific care guidance.”
Tohsssik 5-Pack Stackable Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 70 Cubes, Black
With five trays and 70 cubes total, this Tohsssik set is the volume pick in this group. Each tray makes 14 cubes, so the capacity is easy to calculate, unlike the Weftnom three-pack, which leaves its cube count unspecified. The flexible silicone construction is intended to make release easier than with Arrow’s rigid plastic trays, while included lids help contain spills and odors as the trays stack. It also supports more than water: the description lists cocktails, coffee, whiskey, and frozen treats. The tradeoff is a larger collection to store and clean, and the product data gives no dishwasher or other cleaning instructions. Choose it when filling several batches at once matters more than a compact footprint or clear care guidance.
Pros:- Five trays make up to 70 cubes at once
- Flexible silicone is intended to ease cube release compared with rigid plastic trays
- Lids help contain spills and odors
- Suitable for ice, coffee, cocktails, whiskey, and frozen treats
Cons:- Five trays take more storage space than the Amytor two-pack
- No dishwasher or other cleaning instructions are provided
- Each tray is limited to 14 cubes
Best for: Households and hosts who want to freeze multiple 14-cube batches at once for drinks and frozen treats.
Not ideal for: Buyers with limited freezer space or those who need confirmed dishwasher and cleaning instructions.
- Brand:Tohsssik
- Number of trays:5
- Capacity:70 cubes total; 14 cubes per tray
- Material:Food-grade silicone and polypropylene
- Color:Black
- Shape:Rectangular
- Included components:Lids
- Item weight:0.29 kg
- Dimensions:9.84 × 2.56 × 6.29 in
Our verdict“Pick Tohsssik for a clearly stated 70-cube batch across five lidded trays, provided you have room and can work with the unspecified cleaning guidance.”
NFK Ice Cube Tray Set with Lids and Storage Bin, 4 Trays, 48 Cubes
The NFK set suits buyers who want covered ice stored separately from the rest of the freezer. Its four fitted lids help limit odor transfer, and the included bin gives finished cubes a dedicated place. Compared with the DOQAUS kit, it provides the same four-tray-and-bin setup but does not list a scoop; its flexible silicone bottoms make release easier than a rigid tray design. Each tray holds just 12 cubes, though, so filling a bin for a gathering means more batches than with the Jrisbo eight-pack. The modest cube size also melts faster than larger ice. I’d choose this for regular household use and tidy storage, not for quickly producing a large volume of ice.
Pros:- Four fitted lids help keep freezer odors away from the ice
- Flexible silicone bottoms make cubes easier to release
- Stackable trays and a storage bin help organize freezer space
- Dishwasher-safe construction simplifies cleanup
Cons:- Each tray makes only 12 cubes, so large batches take time
- Smaller cubes may melt quickly and may not suit drinks calling for larger ice
Best for: Households that want lidded, odor-conscious ice storage and a compact four-tray setup
Not ideal for: Hosts who need a large batch quickly or people who prefer larger cubes
- Material:Plastic and silicone
- Tray count:4
- Total capacity:48 cubes
- Cubes per tray:12
- Cube dimensions:1.7 x 1.1 x 0.8 in
- Included components:4 trays and 1 storage bin
- Dimensions:8 x 4.5 x 3.4 in
- Care:Dishwasher-safe
Our verdict“Choose the NFK set for covered, organized everyday ice storage; pick the Jrisbo set if total cube capacity matters more.”
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4 Pack Silicone Ice Bucket Kit
The DOQAUS kit is the most ready-to-serve option in this group: four flexible trays, a storage bin, and a scoop cover making, storing, and serving ice without needing a separate utensil. Its one-push release is a useful distinction from the NFK set, which relies on flexible tray bottoms but does not include a scoop. Spill-resistant lids and stackable parts also suit a compact freezer or RV, where a tilted tray can be a nuisance. The tradeoff is batch size: the product description does not specify cube capacity, and its small individual trays may require repeated freezing for a gathering. Compared with the DOQAUS blue set, this version specifically highlights one-push release and spill-resistant lids, making it a better fit for buyers who value easy handling over a simple storage bundle.
Pros:- Includes four trays, a storage bin, and a scoop
- One-push release avoids twisting or striking the trays
- Stackable design suits compact freezers and RV units
- BPA-free, LFGB-certified components are top-rack dishwasher safe
Cons:- Small individual trays may require multiple batches for gatherings
- The supplied product details do not state total cube capacity
Best for: RV owners and small-household cooks who want a complete, stackable ice-making and serving kit
Not ideal for: People who regularly need a large supply of ice at once or want a clearly stated cube capacity before buying
- Brand:DOQAUS
- Materials:Silicone and polypropylene
- Color:Green
- Included components:4 ice trays, 1 storage bin, and 1 ice scoop
- Dimensions:4.09 x 7.87 x 1.65 in
- Weight:0.38 kg
- Safety:BPA-free and LFGB-certified
- Care:Top-rack dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Pick this kit if you want easy release plus a scoop and storage bin, but look elsewhere for a specified high-capacity setup.”
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray Set with Lids, Storage Bin, and Scoop, 4 Pack
This DOQAUS set brings together the useful accessories—four trays, a storage bin, and a scoop—in a blue, stackable package. Flexible bottoms help free cubes without the force that can crack or bend a rigid tray, while the included bin keeps finished ice gathered in one place. Compared with the green DOQAUS kit, this version’s description emphasizes flexible easy-release trays rather than a one-push mechanism and spill-resistant lids. Its central limitation is that the lids are not airtight: they can help with stacking and reduce spills, but they should not be treated as a seal against strong freezer odors. The product data also gives inconsistent dimensions, so I would not choose it when a precise freezer fit is the deciding factor. It makes more sense as an accessory-rich everyday set.
Pros:- Includes four trays, a storage bin, and a scoop
- Flexible bottoms help release cubes without twisting a rigid tray
- Stackable setup helps keep trays and stored ice organized
- Top-rack dishwasher-safe components simplify routine cleanup
Cons:- Lids are not airtight and may not block freezer odors
- Product listing gives conflicting size information
- Cube capacity is not clearly specified in the provided details
Best for: Buyers who want flexible-release trays, a storage bin, and a scoop for routine home or RV use
Not ideal for: People seeking airtight odor protection or a confidently specified fit for a tight freezer shelf
- Brand:DOQAUS
- Included items:4 silicone ice cube trays, storage bin, and scoop
- Materials:Plastic, polypropylene, rubber, and silicone
- Color:Blue
- Listed dimensions:12 x 7.4 x 3 in; also listed as 8.2 x 4.5 x 3.6 in
- Weight:13.7 oz
- Features:Stackable, flexible easy-release trays with lids
- Care:Top-rack dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Choose this blue DOQAUS set for flexible trays and useful storage accessories, not for airtight sealing or exact-fit planning.”
Rubbermaid Easy Release Ice Cube Tray (2 Pack, Orchid Light Purple)
Rubbermaid is the straightforward pick for buyers who want two reusable trays without a bin, scoop, or multi-part storage system. A water-level indicator helps prevent overfilling, while the stackable design is aimed at freezer storage without trays sticking together. Compared with the NFK and DOQAUS sets, it offers fewer accessories and no listed silicone construction, but its simpler format may suit a buyer who already has a dedicated place for ice. Break-resistant construction and dishwasher-safe cleanup are practical advantages for repeat use. The product details do not specify tray capacity, cube dimensions, or material, so it is harder to compare output and fit against the other options. Its orchid color is also a fixed choice rather than a broad color range.
Pros:- Two trays provide a simple setup without extra components
- Water-level indicator helps control filling
- Stackable design is intended to save freezer space
- Break-resistant and dishwasher-safe construction supports repeat use
Cons:- No storage bin, lids, or scoop are included
- Product details do not specify material, tray capacity, or cube dimensions
- Available color is limited to orchid light purple
Best for: Shoppers who want a simple, durable two-tray setup with a filling guide and no extra storage pieces
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a storage bin, covered odor protection, flexible silicone release, or confirmed cube capacity
- Brand:Rubbermaid
- Pack size:2 trays
- Color:Orchid light purple
- Design:Stackable
- Filling feature:Water-level indicator
- Construction:Break-resistant
- Care:Dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Choose Rubbermaid for a no-fuss two-tray option with a fill guide; choose a lidded kit if storage and odor control matter.”
Jrisbo Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 8-Pack
When the priority is making plenty of ice at home, Jrisbo leads this group with eight trays and 112 cubes of stated capacity. That is more than twice the NFK set’s 48-cube total, although each Jrisbo tray still makes only 14 cubes, so the larger output comes from keeping more trays in rotation. Removable lids help limit freezer odors and let trays stack, while soft silicone bottoms make release easier than a rigid tray. Unlike the DOQAUS kits, Jrisbo does not include a storage bin or scoop; this is a production-focused bundle, not a complete serving station. The listed cubes are also modest in size, and eight trays need more freezer room than a two-tray option. It suits households that can spare that space and want a reserve ready.
Pros:- Eight trays provide 112 cubes of stated total capacity
- Flexible bottoms help release cubes more easily
- Removable lids help limit freezer odors
- Lids support stacking while trays freeze
Cons:- Eight trays take more freezer space than a small two-tray set
- Each tray makes a relatively small 14-cube batch
- No storage bin or scoop is listed
Best for: Large households and frequent hosts with enough freezer space to make and keep a sizable supply of ice
Not ideal for: People with compact freezers, occasional ice needs, or a preference for larger cubes and bundled storage accessories
- Brand:Jrisbo
- Tray count:8
- Cubes per tray:14
- Total capacity:112 cubes
- Materials:Silicone and PP
- Cube dimensions:Approximately 1.8 x 1.3 x 0.9 in
- Colors:4 blue and 4 green
- Lids:Removable
Our verdict“Choose Jrisbo when freezer capacity and a large reserve of covered cubes matter more than a compact footprint or serving accessories.”
How We Picked
I compared these 15 ice cube trays around the decisions that affect daily use: how much ice a set can make, whether the design has lids or a storage bin, how the tray construction may affect release and handling, and how many separate pieces need to be stored or cleaned. I also distinguished tray-only products from sets with bins and scoops, since extra storage can be useful but also takes up more freezer space.
The ranking favors balanced everyday utility over the biggest bundle. The OXO pair leads as a practical covered option; the Kitch trays stand out for a simple traditional format; and larger silicone packs or storage kits rank for specific needs such as batch freezing or organized access. Product names and listed features guide this comparison; I do not claim hands-on testing or assign performance details beyond the information provided.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Ice Cube Trays
Before choosing a set, decide what problem you want the trays to solve. A tray that releases cubes easily may suit daily drinks, while a bin can help keep a larger batch ready; neither advantage matters much if the set crowds your freezer or adds more pieces than you want to clean.
Choose a release style you can handle
Ice release is a frequent source of frustration, but the best design depends on how you remove cubes. Flexible silicone can let you press or twist individual sections, while a more rigid tray may be easier to carry level when filled. Consider whether you usually need a few cubes or empty a whole tray at once. A tray that flexes can be convenient at the sink, yet it may need a firm surface underneath while moving water to the freezer. If you have limited hand strength, prioritize a design that avoids forceful bending or repeated twisting. Avoid buying based on material alone; shape and how you plan to release cubes matter too.
Match capacity to how you use ice
Pack count is not the same as useful capacity: tray size, cube count, and how often you freeze all matter. A smaller household that uses a few cubes per day may get more value from a compact pair than from a multi-tray set. Frequent entertainers or people who chill batches of drinks may prefer several trays, especially if they can freeze them in rotation. Check whether the listed cube count refers to one tray or the whole set before comparing options. More trays can help you build a reserve, but only if your freezer has a flat area where they can sit undisturbed. Think about your actual weekly use rather than choosing the largest set by default.
Decide whether lids are useful in your freezer
Lids can help protect exposed water from spills and nearby freezer odors, and they can make stacking easier when the design supports it. They also add parts that must be matched, washed, and stored after use. A lid does not automatically make a tray leakproof, so fill and carry it cautiously unless the product specifies otherwise. Measure the shelf or drawer height where you plan to freeze trays, including clearance for lids. If you freeze trays beneath other items, a covered, stackable setup may be more practical than an uncovered tray. If your freezer is already crowded, a lid that raises the stack can work against your available space.
Know when a storage bin earns its space
A bin changes the routine: instead of leaving finished cubes in the tray, you can move them into shared storage and keep the trays available for another batch. This can be helpful for steady ice use, but the bin itself needs room and may add washing and handling. A scoop can make serving easier, though it is another accessory to keep track of. Compare a bin kit with a tray-only set by asking whether you routinely run out of empty trays or lose access to frozen cubes. If you already have a freezer-safe container, a separate bin may duplicate something you own. Choose the kit when organized storage solves a real problem, not just because it includes more pieces.
Factor in cleaning and long-term upkeep
Every extra tray, lid, bin, and scoop adds to the cleaning routine, so a large set is not automatically easier to live with. Look for care instructions before purchase, particularly if you plan to put components in a dishwasher. Silicone can be flexible for releasing ice, but odors or residue may call for more attentive cleaning and drying. Rigid trays often have fewer moving pieces, which can appeal to buyers who want a simple routine. Let trays and lids dry fully before stacking them away to limit trapped moisture. If low maintenance is your priority, favor a smaller, uncomplicated setup over a bundle with accessories you may rarely use.
Check freezer fit before prioritizing quantity
A tray must sit flat while water freezes, so available shelf area can matter more than total cube capacity. Measure the intended space and account for the tray’s footprint, lid height, and any bin you plan to keep there. Narrow shelves, crowded drawers, or sloped freezer compartments can make multi-pack sets awkward to use. Stackable designs can save space after freezing, but stacking filled trays requires stable support and enough vertical clearance. If you need to freeze several trays at once, make sure you have room for each one before choosing a high-count bundle. A set that fits your freezer reliably is more useful than extra capacity that cannot be placed level.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose silicone or a rigid ice cube tray?
Choose based on how you prefer to remove ice and handle a filled tray. Flexible silicone designs are suited to pressing or twisting cubes free, while rigid trays can feel steadier to carry when filled. Silicone is not automatically easier for everyone, since bending a full tray may require a secure grip and room to work. Rigid trays may need a different release motion, depending on their construction. If possible, prioritize the release style that feels manageable for your hands and routine rather than assuming one material is universally better.
Do I need an ice cube tray with a lid?
A lid is useful if you want to protect water from spills, freezer debris, or nearby odors, or if you plan to stack trays. It adds height and another piece to wash and store, so it can be inconvenient in a crowded freezer. Lids should not be treated as leakproof unless the product specifically says so. Check your freezer clearance with the lid in place, not just the tray by itself. For a simple setup where trays sit undisturbed, an uncovered option may be enough.
Is a tray-and-bin set worth choosing over extra trays?
A bin set makes sense when you want to transfer finished cubes out of the trays and keep a reserve ready. Extra trays are a better fit when your main goal is freezing more batches at once and you have space to lay them flat. A bin kit adds bulk and may include accessories that need separate cleaning, so it is not automatically the more convenient choice. If you already store ice in a suitable container, another bin may duplicate what you have. Base the choice on whether your current bottleneck is making ice or storing it.
How many ice cube trays should I buy?
Start with how quickly you use ice and how often you are willing to refill trays. A two-tray set can be adequate for routine household use, while a larger pack can help when you need a reserve or freeze several batches in succession. The larger set only helps if your freezer has enough flat space to hold the trays during freezing. Also check whether the advertised cube total covers the whole pack rather than one tray. If your use varies, a moderate set is often easier to manage than buying the largest bundle immediately.
What should I check before buying a multi-pack set?
Confirm the total number of trays, the cube capacity, and whether lids, bins, or scoops are included. Then compare the complete footprint of the set with your freezer, including the height of lids and storage containers. More pieces can support batch-making, but they also create more parts to clean and keep together. Check care instructions and whether the trays are designed to stack while filled or only after freezing. A multi-pack is a good fit when you will use its capacity regularly, not simply because the bundle has more components.
Conclusion
For most shoppers, I recommend the OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Trays, 2-Pack as the best overall choice for a balanced covered-tray setup. The Kitch Easy-Release 2-Pack is my best value-style pick for buyers who want a simpler traditional format, while the four-pack suits people who need more of that same setup. For a premium-style, higher-capacity arrangement, I would look at the DOQAUS set with a storage bin and scoop; its added parts make the most sense when organized access matters. Beginners who want a straightforward starting point can choose the OXO pair rather than a large accessory bundle. For batch freezing, compare the Weftnom or Tohsssik five-packs; for a bin-centered setup, consider NFK or the DOQAUS bin kits. Match the format to your freezer space and ice routine, and skip extra accessories you will not use.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
